Home > Investigating Growth of Organisms > Monarchs
   

   Monarchs

 
Classroom Lessons
Monarch questions & studies
Observing external anatomy and behavior
Life cycle, life history
Change over time, growth rate
Variation in size and growth
Patterns of growth
Big ideas
Resources
    Collecting data - Measurement
   Objectives
 

Overall goals for the measurement lessons:

Students will be able to make accurate measurements.

  • Use the metric system, cm & mm
  • Decide on appropriate untis of measurement
  • Recognize sources of error in measurement
  • Identify and agree on methods for measuring the caterpillar
    • Students need to discuss and agree on how to measure the larvae. This was done using line drawings to decide on which structures to include, and by settling on methods for measuring curved or moving larvae. Two students measured the same larva, and then tried to reconcile the differences in the values they obtained. Sometimes they said these differences were due to using rulers that weren't the same (attributing the difference to the tool, not the methods used). In these cases, they often used an intermediate value as the "real" value, because they could not decide which one of them was "correct." Sometimes they dismissed others' values, sometimes they averaged the two values to include everyone's data.
  • Measure wing area or expansion (in wing expansion activity)
    • We only handled adult butterflies to tag and release them. However, students studied butterfly wing expansion using a set of images taken at intervals in the 15 minutes following butterfly emergence from the chrysalis. When students measured wing area on images of the adult butterfly, they often measured length and width of the wing as non-perpendicular lines, and were not consistent on these measures (across or within groups). This meant that their calculations for wing area (length x width) were based on inconsistent methods and differed substantially even when groups were working with the same image.
   Children's thinking during lesson
 

Understanding measure is not a simple task. Our sixth grade students generally have accurate ideas about the relative sizes of metric units-they know that mm are smaller than cm. They can name some objects that correspond to the different-sized units. Many students have problems with converting mm to cm, or vice versa. They seem confused as to whether they should multiply or divide by 10 when making the conversion. Some students readily convert metric units and use decimal notation correctly.

When reading the ruler, some students do not know how to read the units. They may say "3 and 7 little lines." They may read 3.7 as "3 and a half" even when more precise measurements are needed. Most students attempt to do all measurements in inches, rather than the less familiar metric units. Students sometimes try to measure very small objects in cm instead of mm. Most students are not familiar with expressing fractions and decimals, so, for example, may express "three and a half" as "3.1/2."

Last Updated: February 17, 2005
All Rights reserved